22 Colorful Candy Cookie Pie Ideas to Sweeten Your Life

Ever craved something that’s a cookie, pie, and candy explosion all in one bite? That’s exactly what a Colorful Candy Cookie Pie is—a dessert that doesn’t hold back on fun, flavor, or sugar rush potential.

It’s the perfect mashup for celebrations, movie nights, or just a random Tuesday when you need a little extra joy.

Here’s the ultimate guide to making and customizing 22 different types of candy-packed cookie pies.

Get ready to bake up something bold, bright, and ridiculously delicious!

1. Classic M&M Cookie Pie

You can’t go wrong with M&Ms baked into a giant cookie pie. Their crispy shell adds a delightful crunch, while the melted chocolate inside keeps things gooey.

Pro tip: Use a mix of mini and regular-sized M&Ms for extra texture.

2. Peanut Butter Cup Explosion

If peanut butter is your love language, load your cookie pie with chopped peanut butter cups.

They melt into the dough, creating pockets of peanut buttery goodness.

Anecdote: My cousin once made this, and we finished the entire pie before dinner. No regrets.

3. Funfetti Sugar Cookie Pie

Turn your cookie pie into a confetti explosion with rainbow sprinkles mixed into a sugar cookie base. It’s like a birthday cake and cookie combined.

Stat: Funfetti-based desserts have grown in popularity by 38% over the past five years, especially for kids’ parties!

4. Brownie Stuffed Cookie Pie

Why choose between a brownie and a cookie when you can have both? A brownie-stuffed cookie pie layers gooey brownie batter inside a cookie crust.

It’s the ultimate two-in-one dessert.

Quick tip: Bake the cookie crust for a few minutes before adding the brownie layer to avoid underbaking.

5. S’mores Cookie Pie

Bring the campfire indoors with a s’mores version of a cookie pie. Load it with chocolate chunks, graham cracker crumbs, and gooey marshmallows.

Pro tip: Torch the marshmallows on top for that authentic toasted flavor.

6. Oreo Cookie Pie

Crushed Oreos inside the dough? Yes. Whole Oreos baked on top? Absolutely. This is the cookie pie for cookies-and-cream lovers.

Fun fact: Over 450 billion Oreos have been sold since they were first introduced in 1912!

7. Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

Sometimes, simple is best. A thick, gooey chocolate chip cookie pie is a must-have for any dessert lover.

It’s crispy on the edges and soft in the middle—perfection.

Anecdote: I once made this for a dinner party, and guests fought over the last slice. Lesson learned—always bake two.

8. Salted Caramel Drizzle

A little salted caramel drizzle on top takes any cookie pie from good to gourmet. The sweet and salty contrast makes every bite unforgettable.

Pro tip: Add a pinch of flaky sea salt before serving to enhance the flavors.

9. Cookie Butter Swirl

Biscoff cookie butter fans, this one’s for you. Swirl cookie butter into the dough before baking for a next-level flavor boost.

Quick fact: Biscoff cookie butter was originally a secret European café treat before it became a worldwide obsession.

10. White Chocolate Raspberry

A more elegant take—white chocolate chunks and fresh raspberries baked into a golden cookie pie. The tart berries balance out the sweetness perfectly.

Pro tip: Use frozen raspberries to prevent excess moisture in the dough.

11. Triple Chocolate Overload

Why stop at one chocolate when you can have three? This version uses milk, dark, and white chocolate chips for a deeply rich and indulgent bite.

Stat: 85% of dessert lovers say they prefer desserts with multiple types of chocolate.

12. Skittles Sugar Cookie Pie

Who says chocolate gets to have all the fun? Mixing Skittles into a sugar cookie base creates a fruity, chewy, and colorful twist.

Anecdote: My little niece calls this the “unicorn pie” because of how bright and happy it looks.

13. Nutella Swirl

Swirling Nutella into a cookie pie before baking gives you little rivers of chocolate-hazelnut goodness in every bite.

Pro tip: Warm up a slice and add a scoop of vanilla ice cream for an out-of-this-world experience.

14. Reese’s Pieces Madness

A peanut butter cookie pie loaded with Reese’s Pieces is a guaranteed hit. The crunch of the candy shell and the creamy peanut butter inside = heaven.

Fun fact: Reese’s Pieces became wildly popular after appearing in E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982).

15. Candy Cane Chocolate Chunk

Perfect for the holidays! Crushed candy canes and chunks of dark chocolate make this cookie pie taste like Christmas morning.

Pro tip: Let the pie cool slightly before cutting to keep the peppermint crunchy.

16. Snickers Surprise

Chop up Snickers bars and mix them into your cookie dough. The caramel melts into gooey pockets, and the peanuts add a delicious crunch.

Stat: Snickers is the #1 best-selling candy bar in the world.

17. Gummy Bear Funfetti

Yes, you can bake gummy bears into a cookie pie! They melt slightly, creating little fruity pockets of goodness.

Anecdote: I made this for a kids’ party once, and they called it the “magic rainbow pie.”

18. Twix Cookie Pie

A layer of caramel and shortbread chunks inside a cookie base gives this pie the ultimate Twix bar flavor.

Pro tip: Add crushed Twix pieces on top for extra crunch.

19. Cotton Candy Swirl

Add a little cotton candy extract and pink & blue food coloring to a sugar cookie base for a funfair-inspired treat.

Fun fact: Cotton candy was invented by a dentist in 1897!

20. Rock Candy Crunch

Crush up some rock candy and mix it into your cookie dough for an unexpected crunch and sparkle.

Pro tip: This works best with sugar cookie dough, so the candy’s bright colors pop.

21. Malted Milk Ball Cookie Pie

Crushed malted milk balls (like Whoppers) add a malty, crunchy texture that pairs beautifully with a chocolate cookie base.

Quick fact: Malted milk powder was originally created as a nutritional supplement before becoming a dessert favorite.

22. Chocolate-Dipped Edges

Take any of these cookie pies and dip the edges in melted chocolate for a stunning presentation.

Anecdote: The first time I did this, my family thought I had bought the pie from a fancy bakery!


No matter which of these 22 candy-packed cookie pies you try, one thing’s for sure—it’s impossible to be sad when eating one.

Now, grab your favorite candies and start baking. Life’s too short for boring desserts!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *